Skip to content ↓

Pilgrim’s Progress

Reading Classics Together Collection cover image

Reading Classics Together
A few weeks ago I announced that the next Reading Classics Together project would take on John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress. Reading Classics Together is a simple program: We (that’s me and anyone else who cares to join in) read books in parallel and meet up here to discuss them. If you’d like to participate, you’re not too late. Just start reading!

This week’s assignment was to read the first “stage” of Bunyan’s classic. We’ll be reading it according to the classic chapter (or “stage”) breakdown you can see in the CCEL version of the book.

Now I am going to be perfectly honest with you and admit that I have read Pilgrim’s Progress a few times and have never much enjoyed it. I don’t exactly know why this is. I’ve always wanted to enjoy it, but just haven’t been able to. So when I decided that we would do it as our next classic, I also decided to try reading it differently. Actually, I decided to listen to it. I have to say, so far it’s made all the difference.

The version I have been listening to is narrated by Nadia May and she does a wonderful job of it; the way she reads the text helps explain the text. So far it’s making all the difference. My friends at ChristianAudio have discounted it to just $4.98 in case you’d like to give it a listen as well (add it to your cart and use the discount code Challiesrtc).

Now, on to a discussion of this week’s reading.

The First Stage

I will get our discussion underway with three observations.

First, as I listened to the chapter I was struck by how cliche this type of allegory is. However, I had to remind myself that what Bunyan did was actually completely or near-completely original. What has made it feel cliche is the reality that he has had many, many imitators (though very few peers). He is the one who really defined this genre and the others all follow in his wake.

Second, while I didn’t care so much for the characters Obstinate, Pliable, and Help–I find them rather forgettable–I found myself really taken with Mr. Worldly Wiseman and, even more than the man himself, the way he tried to woo Christian to visit Legality in the city of Morality. There is a man who could help Christian with his burden and what Mr. Worldly Wiseman held out to him was the ease with which he would do it. By veering toward Legality, Christian would avoid his long and difficult journey. Instead, he could be free from his burden while still able to keep living in this world. He did this all with words that seemed sweet, even while they dripped with death. There are so many in the world who are just like that.

Finally, I was challenged by Evangelist in the way he came across Christian a second time. It was not enough for him to meet with Christian the first time; he had to follow up. Christian was weak, he was easily led astray, he had not yet found the wicket gate and had not yet been relieved of his burden. And so Evangelist came upon him a second time to help him correct his course. I prefer to think that Evangelist was deliberate in seeking him out.

Next Week

For next Thursday please read (or listen to) stage two. You may want to consult the CCEL version if the version you are reading has a different chapter breakdown.

Your Turn

The purpose of this program is to read these books together. If you have something to say, whether a comment or criticism or question, feel free to use the comment section for that purpose.


  • New and Notable Christian Books for October 2024

    New and Notable Christian Books for October 2024

    As October draws to its close, I wanted to ensure you know about at least some of the most notable books it brought our way. I did not see quite the quantity of new books I have seen in some previous months, but there were still some special ones. For each, I’ve provided the publisher’s…

  • A La Carte Collection cover image

    A La Carte (October 31)

    A La Carte: What is the Reformation? / More than a list of problems / A surprising story / More than songs of praise / Do elders need to evangelize? / Preach the gospel / and more.

  • From Practice to Perfection

    From Practice to Perfection

    You should stop by someday,” he said. “The orchestra is beginning to learn a new piece. I think you would enjoy hearing them. As promised, he met me in the lobby and led me through a locked door. As we walked down a long hallway, I could begin to hear music coming from somewhere ahead.…

  • A La Carte Collection cover image

    A La Carte (October 30)

    A La Carte: Not the Halloween you remember / How God used the loss of a loved one to save another / Infertility and longing / Daylight saving and spiritual disciplines / Belong and believe? / and more.

  • A La Carte Collection cover image

    A La Carte (October 29)

    A La Carte: When King Charles came to church / Curiositas and the David Platt documentary / Teasing out idolatry in narcissism / Loving people through slow change / Can God forgive without punishment? / and more.

  • Disappointment

    The Practice of Accepting Disappointment

    One of the most important habits you can develop is the habit of accepting that life is full of disappointments. One of the best ways to grow in contentment is to accept the inevitability of discontentment. One of the ways you can be most joyful in life is to be realistic about life, to know…