Skip to content ↓

Fourteen Signs That You Might Be Legalistic

You Might Be Legalistic

The thing about legalism is that it’s far easier and far more satisfying to spot in someone else’s life than in your own. We are masterful at identifying it and calling it out in other people, but not nearly so good at doing so in our own lives. In Pat Nemmers’ book Retractions he offers a list of 14 signs that you might be legalistic. It’s far from the definitive word on the subject, but is perhaps a useful guide to considering whether you—yes you!—are legalistic.

  1. You read your Bible to get a check mark rather than to meet with God.
  2. Your spiritual disciplines define your spirituality.
  3. You refuse to forgive although you’ve been forgiven.
  4. You judge others before you listen to them.
  5. You justify yourself by comparing yourself to others.
  6. You feel the need to point out someone else’s sin publicly.
  7. Your schedule is so tight it doesn’t have room for “If the Lord wills” in it.
  8. You separate your spiritual life from your natural life.
  9. You spend time only with “saved” people.
  10. You love the praise of men more than the smile of God.
  11. You’re more interested in conformity than conversion.
  12. You make little things big and big things little.
  13. You praise only other’s outward deeds.
  14. You reject the truth tellers who come into your life.

  • A La Carte Collection cover image

    Weekend A La Carte (March 22)

    A La Carte: In case I die unexpectedly / The daily midlife crisis / Anora and the end of #MeToo / Building the habit of family worship / We are not Númenóreans / Iain Murray / and more.

  • The Future of New Calvinism

    The Future of New Calvinism

    I was intrigued by Aaron Renn’s recent article The Maturation of New Calvinism. His thesis is that “New Calvinism has shifted from an ‘All-Star team’ model designed to exert influence over the broader evangelical world to a post-superstar model that primarily serves its own community. This represents the maturity of the movement, perhaps putting it…

  • A La Carte Friday 2

    A La Carte (March 21)

    A La Carte: Coming tariffs on books / When God used a stutterer / Not peculiar enough / What leadership is and does / Staring into an abyss / Standards for good writing / Surrender to ministry / and more

  • A La Carte Thursday 1

    A La Carte (March 20)

    A La Carte: My Jesus poster / Stability on an emotional roller coaster / What pastors owe their congregations / Why friction is good for you / Permissive parenting and civilizational decline / Kindle deals / and more.

  • Vote

    The Unique Christian Contribution to Politics

    The relationship of the Christian to the political process is one of those issues that arises time and again and cycle after cycle. It is one of those issues that often generates more heat than light and that brings about more division than unity. Yet I would like to think we can agree that there…